Pleasure Should Be Chosen, Not Expected
Share
Steak and BJ Day: Harmless Joke or Outdated Expectation?
There are a lot of unofficial holidays floating around the internet.
Some are cute. Some are funny. Some are clearly made up after too much wine.
And then there’s Steak and BJ Day.
Depending on who you ask, it’s either a playful inside joke between consenting adults or a low effort attempt at “balancing” Valentine’s Day. But the real conversation isn’t about whether people celebrate it.
It’s about why it exists in the first place.
Where Did This Even Come From?
The holiday is often framed as a “response” to Valentine’s Day. The idea being that Valentine’s is for women, so this day is for men.
Right there is the first issue.
It assumes:
-
Valentine’s is only about women.
-
Men are not benefiting from Valentine’s intimacy.
-
Pleasure is transactional.
-
One day compensates for another.
That framing alone turns intimacy into a scorecard.
And that’s where things start to feel off.
The “It’s Just a Joke” Argument
A common defense is, “Relax, it’s just a joke.”
But jokes reflect culture.
If something relies on gendered expectations to land, then it’s not neutral. It assumes:
-
Who gives.
-
Who receives.
-
Who is expected to perform.
-
Who is supposed to be grateful.
And here’s the quiet part no one says out loud: even when it’s unspoken, expectation is felt.
You can say there’s no pressure. But if someone is anticipating a reward and the other person feels obligated, that’s not playful. That’s emotional mismatch.
Fantasy vs Reality
The fantasy version looks like this:
-
Effortless enthusiasm
-
Perfect timing
-
Steak magically appears
-
Desire switches on at midnight
-
Everyone is thrilled
Now let’s talk about real adult life.
Someone has to:
-
Plan the meal
-
Buy the groceries
-
Cook the steak
-
Clean the kitchen
-
Finish work
-
Manage kids
-
Handle stress
-
Possibly deal with hormones, exhaustion, or illness
After all that, we’re supposed to flip into performance mode because the calendar says so?
That’s not sexy. That’s scheduling.
Desire doesn’t work like a light switch.
When Intimacy Becomes Performative
Here’s the bigger issue.
When intimacy becomes something you perform because it’s expected, it stops being connective.
It becomes transactional.
It becomes:
“I did my part.”
“Your turn.”
“Today is your day.”
And that strips warmth out of something that should be mutual.
In long term relationships, especially in midlife, that dynamic creates tension fast. One person anticipates. The other feels pressure. Nobody wins.
The Language Problem
Even the name itself centers one person’s pleasure.
There’s no built-in mutuality. No balance. No autonomy.
Modern conversations about sex revolve around:
-
Consent
-
Communication
-
Choice
-
Mutual pleasure
-
Emotional safety
This “holiday” skips straight to assumption.
And that’s the real friction.
Because pleasure that’s chosen feels fun.
Pleasure that’s expected feels awkward.
So Is It Always Bad?
Not necessarily.
If a couple talks about it.
If both people genuinely enjoy it.
If it’s playful and mutual.
If it’s freely chosen.
Then go for it.
No one is policing your bedroom.
But if your holiday only works when you already have excellent communication, then the holiday itself isn’t doing anything meaningful.
The real work is how we talk about pleasure year round.
A Better Take
What if instead of one day focused on one person’s pleasure, we normalized:
-
Mutual effort.
-
Sex before steak.
-
Or steak before sex, but by agreement.
-
Checking in instead of assuming.
-
Choosing pleasure instead of performing it.
What if intimacy wasn’t tied to dates at all?
Because here’s the truth:
Desire isn’t a calendar event.
And healthy intimacy isn’t built on obligation.
It’s built on choice.
Final Thought
If Steak and BJ Day makes you laugh, great.
If it makes you uncomfortable, that’s worth examining.
If it makes you feel pressured, that matters.
At the end of the day, the real conversation isn’t about steak.
It’s about how we approach sex in modern relationships.
And pleasure works best when it’s chosen, not expected.